Visibility for Scuba Diving

Visibility is one of the most subjective aspects of diving. Ask 10 people after a dive what they think the visibility was, and you’ll get 9 different answers. The last person will spend a half hour trying to guess.

Defining

Visibility
People generally suck at estimating visibility (“viz”). Why is that? I think it comes down to a lack of common definition. I will attempt to define visibility in concrete terms.

The best place to start for this sort of thing is the dictionary. Webster’s defines visibility as

The distance at which something can be seen.

We’re getting closer, but what exactly is the “something” to be seen? I’ve heard a few options: the distance at which hand signals are no longer recognizable, the distance you can’t see a diver’s bubbles, and the distance at which you can’t distinguish an object. The first might be too strict for general use, but the last two start to get the point. Let’s define visibility as the distance at which an object cannot be discerned. The point at which you can’t tell for sure if that is a diver in the distance is the extent of the visibility.

Measuring

That was the easy part, now comes the hard part. How do we measure viz? Believe it or not, there is an established manner. It requires something called a Secchi disk. The disc is attached to a line and gradually moved from the measurer. The distance where the disk cannot be seen is recorded, with the length of the line being the visibility. Even more advanced methods with higher precision exist using photometers.

That’s nice for Jacques Cousteau, but not for Joe Diver who doesn’t have a Secchi disk on hand.

First of all, don’t feel bad. Viz is hard to guesstimate, but gets easier with experience. Even then, in general a range is a better indicator for estimating viz rather than a hard, fixed number. Try to get the lower end where things get blurry and the upper end where things can no longer be seen. As you get better with distances, this range will get smaller and the “true” viz will probably lie somewhere in between.

One rule with measuring viz for scuba: it measures horizontal distance. Vertical distance can be deceiving, as light from the surface increases visibility. However, it can be useful both for an upper bound on your range (vertical viz will always be higher than horizontal) and for estimating distances, since you always know your depth. Some, as a rule of thumb, define the viz as the vertical visibility (the depth where you can no longer see the surface) minus 3 m / 10 ft. Probably a good guideline, but useless in most of the tropics, where the viz always exceeds the dive depth.

Try to use anything you have to your advantage. Length of a wreck, for instance. You can find this out easily and use it to gauge distances more accurately.

Utilizing

I’ll let you in on a secret: it doesn’t really matter. Viz is cool for bragging (“We could easily see over 100 meters!”), but there aren’t too many practical reasons where an accurate number is necessary. There are exceptions, however. For instance, a photographer probably cares more so than others, since the equipment they take can depend on these numbers.

In general, ranges are fine, and even broad descriptions sufficing as well. A scale that goes something like amazing -> great -> good -> ok -> where’s my buddy? -> I can’t see my hand, is descriptive and covers most situations. Make an educated guess, compare to the guesses of others to refine your estimation abilities, but don’t get too hung up on the ever-elusive viz.


You may also like...

12 Responses to “Visibility for Scuba Diving”

  1. Dragan Donkov Says:

    Very strange how people in different countries measure and think a dive is with good vis. For example here in Malta the average vis is 18-20 meters. Sometimes we have people from UK that are happy with anything more than 5m. This puts them in a great danger because the go deep very fast tempted from the crystal clear water without noticing the actual depth :)

  2. David Says:

    Hi Dragan,

    Thanks for posting!

    Your example really illustrates how subjective visibility is. I went diving in New Zealand where visibility was ~5 meters. Afterwards everyone was talking about how great a dive it was, which was really confusing for this Caribbean kid!

  3. What is Backscatter? Says:

    [...] far away” is dependent on the visibility of the water, with higher visibility tolerating flash from slightly farther distances. However, anything above 3 [...]

  4. Ester Wimberly Says:

    Thanks for this cool sharing of this. How much time did it cause you to create such a website? Did you pay people to do it? Just to share that Alexa bar is a wonderful plugin to track the popularity of your site. Do check it out when you have time. Cheers!

  5. marion Says:

    i think the water can affect the visibility of the diver. i wanna suggest some diving sites there in the Philippines here you can see lovely and colorful marine life from the biggest to the smallest marine life on your list we also have rare marine creatures here then can only be seen in the Philippines hope you can visit soon thank you and have a nice day :) God Bless

  6. David Says:

    @Ester: Thanks for posting! I do all the website work myself. I started from a generic Wordpress theme and manually edited it.

    Thanks for stopping by!

  7. Phuket Scuba Guy Says:

    I really loved that. any more information similar to that is always welcomed. if you post any future news let me know

  8. Diving Koh Tao Says:

    I actually quite enjoy diving in low visibility down below the thermocline. It’s actually quite fun swimming around in the murk.
    Anyhow, there must be a theoretical maximum visibility, in completely clear water (like a spring mountain lake or whatever). I wonder what the max possible visibility is. The most I’ve ever heard reported is 50-60M, but as you point out, how can you be certain that’s an accurate report. It can become very confusing for your eyes in excellent visibility.

  9. Sundance Says:

    You have shed a ray of snusnhie into the forum. Thanks!

  10. pxlvwnni Says:

    b3zm22 rxrsynscmpqm

  11. Koh Tao Diving Says:

    Hi David,

    Great post and a really nicely designed website. Thanks for sharing.

  12. Scuba Diving – What’s It Like When The Water’s All Mucked Up? Musings From A Rogue Diver | Scuba Diving Blog Says:

    [...] continue this muse over at when the water's mucked up. Not only is there pleasure in looking at, and studying, the underwater world, but also divers get a …t out something of special interest to their dive buddy. And there’s the enjoyment of the [...]

Leave a Reply